NOAH KAHAN: OUT OF BODY (B+) - There's emo and then there is Noah Kahan. There are no circumstances in which the sensitive singer-songwriter abbreviates his emotional experiences in this fascinating Netflix documentary that explores his hopes and fears about his recent 15 minutes of fame.
Kahan, known widely for the 2022 title hit from his album "Stick Season," started out by slowly building an online audience before suddenly becoming an unlikely arena rock star, with a heavily young and female fan base. His painfully heartfelt lyrics -- and his willingness to share about his mental-health challenges -- resonates deeply with your typical angsty teenager.
Director Nick Sweeney, with intimate access, captures Kahan at a critical point in his career -- blowing up and drowning in adoration, but keenly aware that this could all end soon. Has he peaked? Should he savor this pivotal moment, hours away from playing Fenway Park? (Turns out, he needn't have worried, at least not yet; he is scheduled to play more baseball stadiums this summer -- including four shows at Fenway, and two each at Wrigley Field and Citi Field.)
Kahan's Vermont family figures prominently in his songs and this documentary. He mourns the change in his father, who never fully recovered from a traumatic brain injury (he sings about "the darkness I inherited from my dad" who "still can't call me back") but who is a trouper here trying to support the son who is living out the old man's musical dreams. His mom is nurturing, and his siblings are supportive and successful in their own right.
The co-star of the film, though, is Vermont, the site of Stick Season, the depressing wintry labyrinth of bare tree limbs that cruelly follows the brilliant fall colors. Kahan grew up in Strafford (90 minutes southeast of Burlington), and he is constantly forsaking places like Boston and Nashville to return to that ghostly New England milieu and its mix of cold and clouds and the scar tissue of his youth. We watch him sit in his old bedroom and try to conjure up the creative muse that energized him in his teens and early 20s. (He just turned 30 this week.) He constantly frets -- about the shallowness of our culture, the fragility of success, his body type. He sweats out the recording sessions for the big-pressure follow-up album (which finally came out this month after a four-year gap in studio releases, to tepid reviews), knowing that it's very possible he cannot top "Stick Season." But despite his dour demeanor, he has a winning sense of humor, and you can see why the kids swoon.
I wish Sweeney had let the songs breathe a little more here, especially the endlessly clever "Stick Season," which could have been fleshed out more as a defining single before the director jumped to its anthem status as an arena singalong. Outside of that big hit, his songs tend to sound the same. (We'll see if the new album recaptures the magic.) He's no vocal tour de force -- he trills in a wispy whisper like Ed Sheeran -- and his song structures don't really stand out from other earnest acoustic-driven balladry like you'd get from the Lumineers or the Avett Brothers. (I'm tempted to say that every generation gets the Don McLean it deserves.)
Nitpicking aside, this is a penetrating character study of a true thinking, feeling human being surviving as a cog in our content-creating culture. There is meat on his bones and on the bones of this patient, observant film. You are likely to root for him at the end of an hour and a half, even if he can be quite a pill who needs to realize there are places to live other than Vermont -- you know, where the sun shines a little more often. Though if he did relocate to a place like, oh, New Mexico maybe, what would he have left to grouse about in song?
OUTCOME (C+) - Jonah Hill is obnoxious and Keanu Reeves is a block of wood in this contrived Apple TV movie about a beloved film star confronting his past sins in the face of a blackmailer threatening to release a mystery video.
Hill directed this cynical attempt at taking down the Hollywood scene (and he co-wrote it with newcomer Ezra Woods). He has a slack visual style, and just about every actor in his cast is off-pitch. That especially applies to Hill himself, hamming it up as the obnoxious lawyer for superstar Reef Hawk (Reeves, going by the singular form of his name, apparently). By far the worst part of Jonah Hill's movie is Jonah Hill. He thinks it's cute or clever or retro to have his character refer to Reef as "bubbe" constantly and to make his star watch him sit on the toilet, LBJ-style; it merely comes off as strained and tone-deaf, a parody of a boorish '50s agent.
Reeves lacks the requisite amount of charisma to pull off a Tom Cruise-like character, and he lacks the acting chops to convey the turmoil and fear of having his empire come tumbling down. (He also lacks the acting chops to convince us that his character has won three Oscars.) He is also stuck in quite the idiot plot, a simplistic narrative with the sophistication of an episode of "Baretta."
Reeves is surrounded by a C-list of co-stars -- how is David Spade still a thing? -- playing the comedy to the rafters. Cameron Diaz -- far beyond her "There's Something About Mary" comedic peak -- is a flop as one of Reef's two loyal high school pals who anchor his entourage and helped cover up his years-long heroin addiction; the other is a stereotypical gay best friend played by Matt Bomer. For some reason we get Martin Scorsese as Reef's former child manager, and Susan Lucci gets dusted off to flaunt her septuagenarian cleavage as Reef's vain mother, a cheap cast member of one of those "Real Housewives" knockoffs. The one bright spot is Ivy Wolk as the motormouth Gen Z slacker assistant.
There is little tension as Reef goes on a sobriety apology tour (apparently a cover as he tries to sniff out the blackmailer's identity), but at least this all gets wrapped up in 83 minutes. All it needed was a different star and a competent director who isn't so in love with his own gags.
BONUS TRACKS
Noah Kahan's hit, "Stick Season," with 63 million views and counting:
From the climax of "Outcome," Kurt Vile (with John Prine) and "How Lucky":


















