LATE FAME (A) - A recent New Yorker cartoon finds a man hunched over a desk, surrounded by piles and boxes of documents, as his wife walks into the room and asks him, "What if nobody wants your papers?" Worse, what if somebody does care about your work from decades ago but it just doesn't matter.
Willem Dafoe captures the pathos of a man who had a brief moment in the sun in his early 20s -- he published a book of poetry in 1979 -- but who is now content to punch the clock at the post office and mix up tuna sandwiches when he gets home. If there ever was a muse, it long left Greenwich Village.
But then he gets rediscovered by a clique of pompous writers in their 20s who lure him out of retirement to join their analog world of trust-fund artistes. Dafoe's Ed Saxberger is flattered, and he is further intrigued when the boys' own muse, the dimestore diva Gloria (Greta Lee), swans into the proceedings to suck up the oxygen in the room with every appearance.
Three powerful lead performances propel this downbeat comic drama from director Kent Jones ("Diane," "Hitchcock/Truffaut"), who paces it masterfully and who knows how to mine the subtle emotions from the calculating script by Samy Burch ("May December"), who adapted a novel from Arthur Schnitzler (who also inspired "Eyes Wide Shut"). The third key player is Edmund Donovan as Meyers (the boys prefer to refer to each other archly by last name), the head of the Enthusiasm Society, a rich kid who knows he was born on third base but who seems to have genuine passion for Saxberger's book ("Way Past Go") and affection for the old poet. His haughty group is resentful of modern slaves to technology and social media, though they haven't given up their cell phones. The members seems to have genuine artistic ambitions as they performatively jockey for positions at this rich boy's Algonquin Roundtable.
The lived-in main characters will actually evolve -- though mostly unravel -- across 96 taut minutes. Saxberger seems torn between savoring the long-overdue recognition and knowing that trying to re-create his youthful accomplishment is a fool's errand. He has been content to hang out with his age-appropriate friends at a corner bar, shooting pool and listening to Lou Reed on the jukebox. It is understandable that he will fall for Gloria, who most surely is overcompensating for insecurities with her exaggerated manner as if she has just escaped Kurt Weill's Berlin and infiltrated Joe College's fraternity during the coonskin Jazz Age.
Lee is mesmerizing, whether she is bantering and flirty or uncorking a couple of torch songs that seemed to genuinely drop the jaws of the extras she performs for. Donovan, too, betrays a certain level of poseur anxiety as Meyers, a charming young man but a directionless writer who could be accused of not having any there there. Actor and character both exude charisma, but Meyers lets slip a little neediness that undermines any confidence he might have had as a young rich white man with New York at his behest. (One of the funniest lines is when Meyers raises a glass and purports to reclaim a forgotten practice: "A toast!")
This is, of course, Dafoe's movie to carry, and there is no other pro who could out-act him in such a role. (It's refreshing to watch him be "normal" here, like in "The Florida Project," rather than ratcheted up in a Wes Anderson freak show.) He has a face that speaks volumes and a Method actor's ease with sorting mail or making a sandwich. Jones knows how to stay out of the way of such performances in pursuit of a finely tuned script.
Burch has an ear for awkward interactions and natural dialogue. When we finally hear one of Saxberger's poems, it zings with grit, gravitas and legitimacy. It all builds to a bittersweet and satisfying conclusion to a minor-key story of three ships that happened to have passed in the night.
THE DRAMA (C-minus) - Dumb and pointless is a deadly combination for a movie. When you don't care about the main couple -- who seem mismatched from the start -- it's difficult to stick around to find out what happens to them.
Zendaya and Robert Pattinson have zero chemistry together, and maybe that's the point, because a drunken revelation by her character, Emma, a week before their wedding ceremony gives him pause and ice-cold feet about going through with the marriage; maybe they are making a mistake after two years of dating. This is another narrative misfire from Norway's Kristoffer Borgli, who struggled in his previous offbeat outing, "Dream Scenario" ("There are some interesting ideas here, but they never gel").
It is just too difficult to care about what happens to these two. Get married, or don't. Life will go on. It is also ludicrous that, with just one week to go until the wedding ceremony, the couple are still taking dance lessons and finalizing the menu, the guest list, the DJ and their vows. This is a movie that takes place in an alternative time-space continuum that is convenient for the plot.
The revelation at the core of the film is also odd and underwhelming. It has to do with something Emma planned to do as a high school sophomore but didn't actually do. Sure, it's disturbing, but it shouldn't necessarily be a deal-breaker more than a decade later for her nerdy British fiance. The revelation comes during a session of "What is the worst thing you've ever done" with their best-friend couple Rachel (an off-key Alana Haim) and Mike (Mamoudou Athie, the best part of the film) while knocking back a few too many wine samples (another thing Emma and Charlie have left to the last-minute, apparently).
Zendaya has a wispy presence in a role that calls for some heft, and Pattinson has been better before, especially in last year's relationship meltdown "Die My Love." It all leads to a ridiculous climactic reveal involving one of Charlie's co-workers along with some improbable wedding toasts. Nobody would act like these characters in real life, and if they did do some of the things Borgli requires of them, why would we care how it all turns out?
BONUS TRACK
The "Late Fame" soundtrack is effective, especially the song over the closing credits (which I could not find). Greta Lee knocks out a spare but rousing version of "Surabaya Johnny," which was recorded by Bette Midler in 1973:

























