A DIFFERENT MAN (B+) - It's an interesting idea: What if you can cure your physical disfigurement but cannot overcome the personality defects that have held you back your whole life? That premise is somewhat successfully explored by writer-director Aaron Schimberg.
Sebastian Stan stars as Edward, a failed actor living in a dumpy New York apartment and suffering from neurofibromatosis, in which tumors enlarge and distort his face. After an experimental treatment, he undergoes a painful but full transformation -- a development around the one-third mark that strains credulity and undercuts the lived-in feel of the first 40 minutes.
Edward had befriended a new neighbor, Ingrid (Renate Reinsve from "The Worst Person in the World"), a self-professed unpublished playwright and alluring free spirit. When the old, recognizable Edward goes missing and the Sebastian Stan version shows up in his place, he claims that Edward committed suicide and he rebrands himself as Guy, who becomes a noted realtor and romeo to hot women. (More credulity-straining.) Flash forward a while, and Ingrid is in rehearsals for her first play -- titled "Edward" and based on the life of her former neighbor. Guy, unsuccessful at finding happiness as a Hollywood-level stud, auditions for the role of Edward -- unrecognizable to Ingrid -- and gets it.
That's a lot of plot development, and we're only halfway through the movie. Let's pause to point out some overall positives: the fine details of Schimberg's script, his ear for offbeat interactions (especially in seedy taverns), and the depth of his characterizations. "A Different Man" is often darkly and bitterly funny. Despite the hiccups of magical realism, it is possible to re-ground yourself each time into an often deeply moving story. Stan is believable as a man now unburdened by disfigurement but still hunched in the shoulders due to the weight of his world -- not just his deception of a woman he aches to be with but also his continued feelings of crushing inadequacy.
This is drawn out once we meet a new rival, Oswald (David Pearson), a man with neurofibromatosis who has personality to burn and lives life to the fullest, lighting up every room he enters, looks be damned. Oswald can sweet-talk women, glibly banter in a pub, and pour his heart out onstage singing karaoke. He is the X-ray opposite now of Guy, whose insecurities seem to be eating away at his insides, just like the experimental drugs chewed away at the tumors covering his face. Pearson (who actually has that condition) has a wonderful swagger, and Reinsve oozes appeal as Ingrid.
And this is an appealing story. The problem is, I couldn't help thinking occasionally, that Schimberg's storytelling skills surface only occasionally and instead get masked and smothered by the conventions of filmmaking, selling us another palatable version of "Cyrano" or "The Elephant Man." This is a very good movie, but Schimberg certainly has an even better one lurking inside him.
ALL WE IMAGINE AS LIGHT (B-minus) - What a precious, delicate debut feature about three women from provincial villages struggling to live independent lives while working at a hospital in the big city of Mumbai. It's a shame that it feels so antiseptic and anticlimactic most of the time.
Prabha (Kani Kusruti) has an estranged husband from an arranged marriage who works in Germany. She lives with the more free-spirited Anu (Divya Prabha), a fellow nurse who is quietly dating a Muslim man while her family back home tries to match her up online with more suitable suitors. They are friends with a hospital cook, Parvaty (Chhaya Kadam), who is facing eviction from her apartment so that another skyscraper can be built in its place.
Prabha rebuffs the advances of a doctor, citing her marital status, descending into a mopiness that is not much fun to watch. Anu is more fun and modern, but the whole storyline of forbidden love with a dream guy has nothing to say beyond the standard rom-drama tropes. The script rarely rises above cliches, like when a character bemoans, "You can't escape your fate." Too many scenes drag in a film that clocks in just shy of two hours. One of the bright spots involves a pregnant household cat, but that plot line gets abandoned without resolution.
Writer-director Payal Kapadia, schooled in documentaries, certainly has an elegant touch behind the camera. But one of the main points of her film is that these women from small towns are facing a challenge in the hustle and bustle of Mumbai -- yet she oddly insulates the women from the noise and grit of the city, which often are rendered merely as background material, all artsy and muted. There doesn't seem to be a connection between the women and the city life exploding all around them. A switch of venue in the second half to Parvaty's small town offers hope to reignite the flagging story, but again we are treated to artifice and mood rather than the true hum of real life. As a result, a bittersweet ending lacks the punch it deserves. It all feels like a missed opportunity.
BONUS TRACKS
"A Different Man" has a delightfully raunchy soundtrack. Here is "I Owe It to the Girls" by Teddy and the Frat Girls:
The Cramps also show up. Here is the swaggering "I Can't Hardly Stand It":
And here's a palate-cleanser. Oswald croons a heartfelt version of this '70s classic, Rose Royce's "I Wanna Get Next to You":